3 Ideas About Scary Performance Screw-Ups by Mac Logan
3 Ideas About Scary Performance Screw-Ups?
first published November 2021
Failure hurts. Like navigating a storm, performance problems often surface in difficult times and during the toughest situations.
Do management and effectiveness always go hand in hand? How long do promises of fantastic, cost-effective results stand up to the test of delivery? How often do they morph into disappointment, financial losses or worse?
When things come unstuck, commitments and good intentions may become enmeshed in an infuriating tangle of waffle, power struggles, reinterpreted goals, vague performance measures and revised, knee-jerk agendas.
Close examination, objective measurement and fearless reporting may, if the courage exists to face things, uncover troublesome stumbling blocks. Stumbling blocks are, of course, opportunities for improvement.
Complexities and cynicism go well together:
- Policy involves powerful people: politicians, mandarins, advisers; thought processes include accepted thinking, ideology, concepts, dogma; delegated responsibility means clean hands, expedience and a tendency towards buck-passing. Coalface experience and hard-won expertise is often, at best, overlooked… at least during a hiatus.
- Action relies on somewhat powerful people: seniorish politicians, officials and consultants; an embattled working style, diverted at times yet busy, pressurised and focused on sounding competent. Fearful responsibility means pushy orders, bossing the troops and even looming consequences. Demanding results without empathy and support is less motivating than a noisy person might like, for sure.
- Delegation passes to low-to-no-power people in the middle and downwards. All roles are blameable and powerless. The true capability and problem-solving capacity of “junior” leaders is often overlooked. Such people are knowledgeable, experienced, sometimes cynical, invariably pressurised, yet (raise your eyebrows) often committed. Coalface experience may be present yet typically ignored.
Through performance problems, one is likely to face some prickly parts of their dysfunctional world… factors that can be fixed if the heart, commitment and leadership exist to tackle them. Talk about scary.
Are damaging screw-ups inevitable?
How often do we hear weasel-worded excuses for failure from faux-contrite ministers? Politicians who, at the outset, exuded confidence and backed all with trenchant promises.
At the simplest level, certain elements that lead to performance failure prove tricky to pin down because of factors like:
- insufficient comprehension of reality
- incomplete planning
- feeble budgetary control
- a top-down communication style (institutional deafness)
- limited and non-scientific measurement and follow-up
- dissembling, fudging and invisibility when things start to go wrong (as they will)
Without a doubt, ineffective diagnosis, management and project planning at the highest levels doom or damage government projects long before their implementation. Long before they are found out. Why do we routinely accept bravura avoidance of accountability for endemic failure, cost overruns, and delays? Would things be different if leaders spent their own money?
Sometimes I wonder whether the world is being run by smart people who are putting us on or by imbeciles who really mean it. Laurence J. Peter, The Peter Principle
Promises, Promises
Hope springs eternal, but effectiveness requires know-how, competence and pragmatism. In the beginning, we may be promised superb outcomes… everything will be achieved on time, within budget, and with absolutely no possibility of failure. How well does your experience match such optimism?
When you get right down to it, enabling excellent outcomes depends on three overlapping worlds cooperating, communicating and engaging. Achieving such success involves three factors, as mentioned above:
- Make Policy
- Implement Action
- Deliver Results
Experience may cast doubt on our politicians’ delivery effectiveness and highlight their hubris. Imagine the electorate’s delight if political promises at the outset perfectly matched outcomes on completion.
If costs overrun, timescales slip, and projects fail, why do we re-elect incompetents, time after time? Should we (can we?) insist on a change in how our electoral system operates – its norms, weaknesses, fudging and cupidity?
It can’t be denied that in the UK, no matter how excellent the policy aspirations are or how much money is committed, delivery is seldom on time and outcomes may not match expectations. For example, the Universal Credit project, the failed NHS records system, and HS2 spring to mind. Whatever the excuses (think Grenfell or reduced red tape from Brexit), these screw-ups cost UK citizens massive amounts of money, material and misery for minimal return and even less accountability. Politicians should make unambiguous, measurable statements about what they will deliver. Regular presentations should show unambiguous, easy-to-understand data. Projects are learning processes. One reporting area should focus on learning.
Screw-ups and failure
UK policymakers create and sell manifesto commitments. Beyond that, things may get hazy. Along with the lack of detail, management and control may become foggy and factional the nearer you get to the coalface. As a result, government projects tend to be delayed, miss targets, and cost far more than expected. Many fail without a trace.
When an election is won, politicians are like werewolves transformed by moonshine. Transfigured by election victory and promotion, shiny, incredibly important people (ministers) hurtle in and out of events, dripping with power, surrounded by a defensive shield of officials. How do the people at the top keep in reliable touch with the getting-things-done real world?
Maybe they don’t. Inevitably, status being what it is, top policymakers may avoid events run for their policy interpreters or policy implementers, apart from keynote drop-in/rush-off sessions.
Cruel and dishonest work environment
Policy Makers (deities all) depend on Policy Interpreters (mostly relatively senior) and Policy Implementers (less senior) to deliver their desired outcomes. How do people achieve high performance in a capricious and highly pressurised working environment?
The top people don’t get it
For one thing, if top people “don’t get it” in the real world, it inevitably leads to performance failures. What’s more, knee-jerk reactions can force change on a whim. Thus, well-intentioned manifestos can be doomed by a lack of expertise and delivery weaknesses. How can we avoid the impact of an autocratic, non-listening, oppressive and childish culture? Might tots have helpful insights to share?
How much opportunity, capability and insight is ignored and wasted? As a result, how much potential and possibility goes down the tubes along with the billions lost to “Fraud and Error”?
A road to hell?
What happens to effectiveness in a world free of accountability? Is the process for getting things done well and on time broken? When delivery begins without insight and ends in disaster, is it because there are no inevitable consequences for poor performance or failure? Waffle works. Why bother? Mañana.
Problematic culture – flaky bubble
Secure in a bubble of ideology and inner-circle compliance (or else), fine-sounding policies are created and instructions issued. Thereupon, delivery mechanisms groan to half-life. Why, one may ask, does self-evident incompetence and routine disaster fail to shock us? What price the soundbites of (never quite) plausible deniability? Are promises to “learn the lessons” a fair conclusion?
Groupthink
As Irving Janis coined the term ‘Groupthink’, meaning:
…a psychological phenomenon where the desire for group harmony, consensus, or conformity overrides critical evaluation, leading to irrational or dysfunctional decision-making.
Using his idea, it seems we are victims of 3 potential pitfalls :
- A dysfunctional decision-making process at the top.
- Corporate unawareness of or ignoring practical, thrifty and humane options for action.
- The irrational avoidance and discouragement of ‘non-supportive’ opinions
Why don’t we demand better? Much, much, much better? If we can’t change and improve (big time), we’ll inevitably end up where we’re heading. Now there’s a leadership challenge. Large Scotch, anyone?
© Mac Logan

One thought on “3 Ideas About Scary Performance Screw-Ups by Mac Logan”